Sorry about not posting lad's this and that, life's hitting like a sack of bricks with work and education happening at once. I'll try to post up soon though.
Strange, it seems your response in this post says otherwise. Either you're shitting on anarchists, implying Puigdemont and/or the MPs are anarchists, both, or neither. Which is it?
From the article I linked earlier: "[Joan Tardà] added that the response of the Catalonian government had been “sharp and resounding” but said that those who “crave” violence “are going to stay with that desire”."
Calling vandalism symbolic is a form of apologism? How do you figure that?
It seems you're not being consistent about which group you're referring to
When I said "democratic separatists", I was referring to Puigdemont and the Parliament
It wasn't intended to counter your statement.
You: Take that anarchshits.
Me: You mean democratic separatists.
You: As it stands I don't believe in your bullshit so no
Me: Are you implying that President Carles Puigdemont is an anarchist, and the Parliament of Catalonia is full of other anarchists? Because they're the ones that led the referendum. If so, I'd love to see your evidence for that claim.
You: Have you seen them decry it a single time, like conservatives are expected to decry the kkk and other such movements? Anyway, you don't really provide any evidence beyond what can be referred to as "alternative facts."
You seem to be implying they're anarchists, rather than democratic separatists. Where's the evidence?
So, you're just making a baseless claim.
I did read the article, but I made a mistake about what Boya said. I've also admitted to making other mistakes, specifically about the number of seats for certain parties, and pointed them out for the sake of being honest.
Good thing those two are the spokespeople for their respective parties
You still haven't provided evidence that they're not democratic separatists.
I asked you if you were implying that they're anarchists, and you didn't say no. Rather, you asked if they had decried the illegal actions of certain anarchists, as if they were expected to do so. Should I have interpreted your reply as a no?
What "alternative facts"?
That assumes Assemblywoman Boya is actually an apologetic. If she is, which has yet to be proven, it's more like a 7v1, because Tardàis and Boya are the spokespeople for their respective parties.
Here's what I said:
You mean democratic separatists.
You're implying that Puigdemont and the Parliament are anarchists, simply because they didn't decry them, so I pointed out that Tardàis did just that. You then corrected my inaccurate statement that Boya also decried them, but her words didn't explicitly condone the vandalism.
Basically, your point can be summarized as an argument from ignorance, which is a fallacy.
I already showed you that Congressman Joan Tardàis decried the vandalism that was purportedly done by anarchists, and he even stated that people may try to link the vandalism to the independence movement. While I agree that Popular Unity Candidacy may be pro-anarchist, you've yet to provide hard evidence that President Carles Puigdemont or the majority of Catalonia's Parliament are pro-anarchist. Until you do that, my premise that they're just democratic separatists still stands, because they're the ones that initiated the referendum.
I mean, if you're just shitting on a bunch of anarchists, that's a different story. If so, you should withdraw your implication that the President and majority of Parliament are on their side.
Thanks for correcting me, but Popular Unity Candidacy isn't exactly a big party, and you've yet to provide evidence that President Puigdemont is an anarchist, or that a vast segment of the Parliament of Catalonia supports violent anarchism. As it stands, CUP only makes up around 14% of the pro-independence side, and 8% of the Parliament. Is that enough to deem the pro-independents and Parliament pro-anarchist?
Actually, yes, I have.
<Snipped quote by Andreyich>
<Snipped quote by Andreyich>
Are you implying that President Carles Puigdemont is an anarchist, and the Parliament of Catalonia is full of other anarchists? Because they're the ones that led the referendum. If so, I'd love to see your evidence for that claim.
I'm thinking the anarchist movement in Catalonia is like the Neo-Nazi movement in the conservative party. Is it there? Yes. Is it the main body of them? No.