Also, you should probably come up with less Warrior-sy names for ranks.
General Shenanigans was just a mix of Sgt Slaughter and Doink the Clown that I made up, but I like the dolphin head
I will eventually make a new post.
Dolphin moves
Speaking dolphin
Argument about if they're fish or mammals
Salty
<Snipped quote by Squashedquatch>
Once I introduce you, you can write IC
@Squashedquatch
Very interesting!
I'll PM you so we can discuss Halandar's backstory in a little more detail and figure out what your lost item is. ;)
Aight, review time.
@Duthguy I like this guy. He's cool.
...
That's all the review you get. Go ahead and add Zerry into the Character tab.
@Squashedquatch Sorry I didn't get back to you as fast as I said I would. I've only just now had the chance to take a proper look at everyone's apps.
I appreciate that you fixed what I told you to, truly. That's exactly why I'm mad at myself for not seeing this earlier.
<Snipped quote by Squashedquatch>
I... honestly don't know what I can tell you about this statement in particular, except that it's cursed. For the future, you really should just throw in bits and pieces of detail into your apps anyway, even if you don't believe it to be relevant to what a GM asks of you, or whatever else. For the moment though, I don't care whether or not you replace the quoted statement with anything; I'd rather just not have to see that it's still there, for my sanity's sake.
I feel as though there's a continuity issue here too, within the bio itself. The Honorstar Garrison Raid was an extremely chaotic battle; realistically speaking, everyone would be too busy fighting for their own lives to pay much attention to one lone guy's mad sniping. What you could do is have your guy had sniped off who he could in the fight, bailed upon spotting the reinforcements and later chanced upon the other survivors as he entered the tavern, using that opportunity to offer his help instead. That should fix the continuity issue I'm getting here, hopefully without interfering with what you wanted.
@ColouredCyan You certainly have the interesting character in the making. If not for the few things here and there, I'd be more than happy to accept it.
Re-Appropriator is not a crew role that I had thought of; I'd just assumed that the cat burglar aspect was something Nami did on the side, prior to officially joining the Straw Hats. Unfortunately, Re-Appropriator is also not a crew role that's on the list. I'll need a moment to consider how such a role would actually help the Sea Reaver Pirates overall, niche applications aside.
Judging from what you've written for the field itself, I'd class Poppy's combat role as a Corsair. They're more focused on quick-draws and rapid shooting than lining up their shots. You can always transfer what you've written in the Combat Role field to the Fighting Style field on the off-chance you wanna save it, but I'll leave that up to you.
That's all for now. I'll establish a due date for apps to be completed when I've finished setting things up.
<Snipped quote by Squashedquatch>
Yeah... I get that this is a WIP, but there are already glaring problems with it.
...
I'll address the fact that you put Sniper in both roles first. If you want your guy to strictly be there as a sniper (which I'm guessing you do), then your crew role would be Enforcer. Just so you know, the Enforcers are the primary combatants of a crew, and they're there to engage the enemy, protect the rest of the crew etc.; in other words, they're pretty much the muscle.
I won't harp too much on the fact that you also just put Sniping in the Fighting Style segment cause that does scream placeholder, although I will say that if you don't expect your guy to fight all that differently from the usual sniper, you might be better off removing the field in its entirety.
...
The second issue is your mention of Portgas D. Ace. I'm not sure how I feel about canon characters even being referenced in a cursory manner, and I'm certainly against the idea of them being personally interacted with. I'd suggest removing all mention of Ace just to be safe :/
...
That's all for now. If you need any help, just ask