Ah, in that case I'll throw in the post I've been sitting on and hope that it doesn't become a "too many cooks" thing. At least give everyone visual contact to set up for later on, if nothing else.
DarkwolfX37 Member
Absolute L User
STATUS: "I've spent a lot of time thinking about my past... My mistakes... And I've come to the conclusion that I was right about everything." 2 yrs ago
- Last Seen: 1 mo ago
- Joined: 12 yrs ago
- Posts: 8493 (1.87 / day)
- VMs: 5
-
Username history
- DarkwolfX37 12 yrs ago
-
Latest 10 profile visitors:
-
Most recent →
The World,
Delgado,
TruckKun,
Scarifar,
Threads of Fate,
Dark Cloud,
Tribs,
Taku,
XoXKieroBombXoX,
YuyouIamHere3
Status
Recent Statuses
2 yrs ago
Current
"I've spent a lot of time thinking about my past... My mistakes... And I've come to the conclusion that I was right about everything."
2
likes
3 yrs ago
"What you know will kill you but you will die laughing."
1
like
3 yrs ago
Hey, you know what's annoying? Being self-centered. Getting mad at people for doing something instead of something else when they're just having fun sucks. Gotta love self-loathing, too.
3
likes
3 yrs ago
"You were last seen the day you disappeared."
1
like
3 yrs ago
"There will always be shitheads. That's why they'll always try to out-shit them." - yourMoonstone | Reminder that all fanart is illegal. |
1
like
Bio
Important News
Important Quotes
Most Recent Posts
<Snipped quote by DarkwolfX37>
Nope. Resource sharing isn't possible.
That's dumb.
Okay so can I use my comp's processor because constant crashes is annoying.
Blood+
<Snipped quote by DarkwolfX37>
The best kind of help.
It is?
Castle
If I can ever figure out a mage CS, I'd be interested. I have a servant sheet lying around from an rp that never took off. Quite a few questions though, because I foresee this getting very out of hand very easily.
Kinda sucks that you banned Accelerator, but I don't see Medaka Kurokami, half the cast of One Piece... Kamijou Touma and Kamisato Kakeru ffs. In fact, just banning the main characters from a lot of those characters' series leaves some equally powerful characters available.
I guess I don't understand if you plan on the characters simply being as they are in their series but brought to a new world, or if you plan on the characters being morphed to fit the mold of Fate servants. For example, Accelerator pre-brain damage or post-WW3 would be obviously overpowered if brought in as-is, but there's an argument for him not being too powerful if he's remade under Fate's rules and had his battery power limit. Similarly, it's odd to ban Light Yagami since his power comes from an item and specifically requires someone's full name, something that Servants already hide on principal. Even with the Death Note as his Noble Phantasm, in order for it to work he'd need to somehow learn a target's name, and giving it some magic reason to not work on non-servants would be easy. Even just "he's a servant and it's not an actual Death Note but a power resembling it, thereby making it only work on Servants/those not participating in the HGW" would suddenly make him logically viable.
There's also the question of how faithful to the character's origins they have to be. What about multiple sources, such as Frost from DBS? His character in the anime and manga are very different from each other. To use an ambiguous example, Chara from Undertale raises some questions. There's very little canon information about them, and a lot of what's there is fairly up for interpretation. How would a Servant like that work? How much of a character can fit into their Servant self before having to allocate traits to their NP? Can a fictional character be used as a Master or only Servants? Either way, does the content they originate from exist in-world or are they totally unknown and only work through some new system that bypasses the need for a legend? Are Servants summoned randomly or is a suitable catalyst still needed?
Does this war use the Stay Night, Extra, Extella, or Grand Order system, or a brand new one? Are class statistics important or are they more suggestions than rules, and to what degree?
Are you expecting players to have multiple characters beyond the one Servant/one Master per player, or are you planning to try to get all of those character slots filled separately? If fictional characters are allowed as Servants, does that mean fictional OCs are allowed? At what point does diversion from the source character into an OOC version does a character stop being allowed? What about multiple versions of the same character appearing as Servants? Further, what about the potential for Lily, Alter, etc. versions of characters from non-Fate series? Would Lily Goku be acceptable, for example? What about imaginary characters within a series, such as Suzushina Yuriko? If someone didn't use a fictional character, how much freedom do they have in making an actual historical or real-life mythological person into a Servant? What about summons into classes that don't necessarily make sense right away, like Gilgamesh's various class summons or Lancer Artoria for example. Could Krillin be summoned as a Saber, for example, because his Distructo-Disc is a cutting technique? Would he be able to be a Rider because he can fly, or an Archer because of his ki blasts, or would he be forced into Caster because of his ki usage, etc.?
Sorry for all the questions, but if this actually takes off I'd be pretty interested and I want to have a solid understanding of the rules and world before I try to make any CSs.
Kinda sucks that you banned Accelerator, but I don't see Medaka Kurokami, half the cast of One Piece... Kamijou Touma and Kamisato Kakeru ffs. In fact, just banning the main characters from a lot of those characters' series leaves some equally powerful characters available.
I guess I don't understand if you plan on the characters simply being as they are in their series but brought to a new world, or if you plan on the characters being morphed to fit the mold of Fate servants. For example, Accelerator pre-brain damage or post-WW3 would be obviously overpowered if brought in as-is, but there's an argument for him not being too powerful if he's remade under Fate's rules and had his battery power limit. Similarly, it's odd to ban Light Yagami since his power comes from an item and specifically requires someone's full name, something that Servants already hide on principal. Even with the Death Note as his Noble Phantasm, in order for it to work he'd need to somehow learn a target's name, and giving it some magic reason to not work on non-servants would be easy. Even just "he's a servant and it's not an actual Death Note but a power resembling it, thereby making it only work on Servants/those not participating in the HGW" would suddenly make him logically viable.
There's also the question of how faithful to the character's origins they have to be. What about multiple sources, such as Frost from DBS? His character in the anime and manga are very different from each other. To use an ambiguous example, Chara from Undertale raises some questions. There's very little canon information about them, and a lot of what's there is fairly up for interpretation. How would a Servant like that work? How much of a character can fit into their Servant self before having to allocate traits to their NP? Can a fictional character be used as a Master or only Servants? Either way, does the content they originate from exist in-world or are they totally unknown and only work through some new system that bypasses the need for a legend? Are Servants summoned randomly or is a suitable catalyst still needed?
Does this war use the Stay Night, Extra, Extella, or Grand Order system, or a brand new one? Are class statistics important or are they more suggestions than rules, and to what degree?
Are you expecting players to have multiple characters beyond the one Servant/one Master per player, or are you planning to try to get all of those character slots filled separately? If fictional characters are allowed as Servants, does that mean fictional OCs are allowed? At what point does diversion from the source character into an OOC version does a character stop being allowed? What about multiple versions of the same character appearing as Servants? Further, what about the potential for Lily, Alter, etc. versions of characters from non-Fate series? Would Lily Goku be acceptable, for example? What about imaginary characters within a series, such as Suzushina Yuriko? If someone didn't use a fictional character, how much freedom do they have in making an actual historical or real-life mythological person into a Servant? What about summons into classes that don't necessarily make sense right away, like Gilgamesh's various class summons or Lancer Artoria for example. Could Krillin be summoned as a Saber, for example, because his Distructo-Disc is a cutting technique? Would he be able to be a Rider because he can fly, or an Archer because of his ki blasts, or would he be forced into Caster because of his ki usage, etc.?
Sorry for all the questions, but if this actually takes off I'd be pretty interested and I want to have a solid understanding of the rules and world before I try to make any CSs.
Sounds interesting. I'm always glad to see new "everyone rping makes the world together" ideas. Here's hoping you succeed with this.
<Snipped quote by DarkwolfX37>
It's not dumb. It's a physical limitation.
It... it's not? Run the program that's on the phone on the computer or vice versa while it's connected. The limitation isn't physical.
<Snipped quote by DarkwolfX37>
It's impossible. If it were, it wouldn't help.
That's dumb. My phone can't run this shit very well and a new phone isn't going to work.
© 2007-2026