Avatar of Letter Bee

Status

Recent Statuses

21 hrs ago
Current Can't believe that I actually got an RP close to its endgame, btw...
4 likes
22 days ago
Noble Arms is now either four years old, or three years and eleven months. The third thread had lasted for more than one year.
1 like
1 mo ago
New Interest Check, everybody!
2 mos ago
My Roleplay, Noble Arms: The ASEAN War, will reach its 4th year in June or July. It's been a long journey.
1 like
2 mos ago
Despite its massive flaws, my RP, Noble Arms: The ASEAN War, is still one of the longest ongoing RPs in RPGuild - It turns 4 years old in July and the current thread itself is more than a year old.
5 likes

Bio

User has no bio, yet

Most Recent Posts

@Mihndar, Poland claims Crimea?


<Snipped quote by Letter Bee>

Rojava's in open revolution. If not to simply maintain its territories against enemies at open war with it then its goals is to at least turn Syria 180 degrees from Assad. But it's only got two real options, it's not like it's going to invade Turkey. Hell, if anything it'll leave the Turkish Kurds to their own decisions once the PKK members serving in Rojava now go home with more battle experience and a rallying cry for their own communities; assuming Rojava survives.

But in cases like the Ukrainian Free Territory, Revolutionary Catalonia, or even the EZLN the name of the game isn't so much to exert ideological power against someone else but to protect what they got from someone else. Historically speaking, the primitive socialism practiced by much of the world before feudalism or even modern capitalism wasn't as organized as the feudal monarch or the corporation to go on the offensive. From a tankie perspective, this is why figures like Lenin are good because they embody enough state centralization to organize resources to go on the counter offensive, where as figures like Makhno may be looked at as the romantic cause that got lost; incapable of seizing extra-territorial power due to the decentralized nature of the commune.


Can I retcon my Philippines to be a regular Federal Republic with some trappings of Syndicalism instead, then?
<Snipped quote by Letter Bee>

It takes a lot of organization and cash to project your power beyond your own country. A decentralized syndicalist nation wouldn't have a central body powerful enough to go through the work of invading overseas.

Its like how the UN doesn't really have power projection. The UN is not centralized, so it cannot project any hard power, it has to rely on the willingness of its members to project that power in its name.


What about Rojava IRL?

Edit: Or is Democratic Confederalism sufficiently different from Syndicalism? I seem to recall Rojava having a federal structure elected from bottom-up...
<Snipped quote by Letter Bee>

I'm not sure a syndicalist system would have the mechanisms to do that.

<Snipped quote by Letter Bee>

If anything reactionaries will have an advantage in PoW world due to the fact that there is no Hitler or WW2.


1.) Oh? Tell me more?

2.) True.

Anyway, as my post draft seems to contradict established lore and potential player's ambitions, mind if I post it here so that people can point out inconsistencies and problems?
And [@TaroAndSeila].
And [@Taro and Seila]
I will wait for @Etranger.
Yeah, WW1 historically destroyed the credibility of reactionary and monarchism in terms of politics. That's not the case. If anything, our Great War proved Monarchism is more then capable of standing up to Democracy. So reactionary governments around the world are for more credible amd likely. Won't stop the rising tide of the left though.


To be fair, the reverse can be construed; Democracy is more than capable of standing on equal terms with Monarchism?
<Snipped quote by Letter Bee>

We could give a pass to a few colonies, but most of them should have broke loose. Hell, it's 1960, in the real world where the French and British won two world wars most of the colonies were gone by then anyway, so in a world where Europe suffered more instability, they should have less of a hold on the colonies. .


Ah, so, if I do not change my post, I would be trying to overthrow already-independent states and set up Syndicalist governments over them.
© 2007-2026
BBCode Cheatsheet